Quick answer: To sell an Erie home next to Westerly's advertised 4.99% builder rate, price against the buyer's monthly payment, not the sticker. On a $750,000 home with 10% down, a $15,812 seller credit funds a 2-1 buydown that cuts year-one payments by about $872 a month. A $25,000 price cut saves about $151.
By Nick Ahrens, Colorado real estate broker license FA.100104470, eXp Realty
Published November 14, 2026.
How do you sell an Erie home when builders are advertising 4.99%?
You compete on the buyer's monthly payment, because on a $750,000 Erie home with 10% down, a 4.99% builder rate puts principal and interest about $921 a month below the 7.11% 30-year fixed average. A $15,812 seller credit for a 2-1 buydown wins back about $872 of that in year one. A $25,000 price cut wins back about $151. Nick Ahrens, a North Denver relocation specialist with eXp Realty, runs this payment math before an Erie list price is set in a builder neighborhood.
Here is the side-by-side on a $750,000 price with 10% down, a $675,000 loan and a 30-year payment schedule:
- Builder financing at 4.99%: about $3,619 a month in principal and interest.
- Resale at the 7.11% average: about $4,541 a month, using the Freddie Mac PMMS 30-year fixed average of 7.11% as of November 12, 2026.
- Monthly gap: $4,541 - $3,619 = about $921.
- Your $15,812 buydown credit, year one: the rate drops to 5.11% and the payment to about $3,669, about $872 less.
- Year two: the rate is 6.11% and the payment about $4,095, about $446 less.
- A $25,000 price cut instead: the loan falls to $652,500 and the payment drops about $151.
The buydown math: 12 x ($4,541 - $3,669) = $10,461 for year one, plus 12 x ($4,541 - $4,095) = $5,351 for year two, for a total of about $15,812. The buyer's lender sets the actual note rate and the exact subsidy, so treat this as an estimate.
Sources and as-of dates: Westerly move-in-ready page and offer terms, Freddie Mac PMMS (week of November 12, 2026), Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, Redfin Erie housing market (three months ending October 2026) and the Colorado Association of REALTORS October 2026 release (November 12, 2026), all checked November 14, 2026. Payments are principal and interest only.
What this guide does not cover: taxes, insurance, HOA dues or metro district levies in the payment, FHA or VA loan limits, permanent buydown pricing, which varies by lender, or advice on buying new construction. This is general information, not lending or legal advice. Get a written quote from the buyer's lender.
What is the builder offer in Erie, exactly?
Westerly advertises a 4.99% initial rate with 10% down on select SLC Homes inventory, and that rate is on a 7/6 adjustable-rate mortgage, not a 30-year fixed. Per the offer terms on the Westerly move-in-ready page, the rate is fixed for the first seven years and may adjust every six months after that. The offer runs through SLC Lending and depends on availability, borrower qualification and credit approval.
What that page listed on November 14, 2026:
- 36 move-in-ready listings, mostly from SLC Homes, McStain and DRB Homes.
- Villas from $550,000.
- SLC single-family homes from $750,000 to $1,100,000.
- Highest list price: $1,699,900.
Two things follow for a resale seller. First, the builder competes on payment, so your buyer will compare your home to that $3,619 number, not just the price. Second, a 7/6 ARM and a 30-year fixed are different loans. Your buyer gets a rate that never adjusts, and that is worth saying out loud in your marketing.
Selling near new construction in Erie?
Send me your address. I'll pull the builder listings and offers your buyers are seeing, price your home three ways, and show you what a buydown credit versus a price cut does to your net.
Call or text me: 949-230-3625, or get a broker valuation on your home.
How big a price cut would match the builder's payment?
About $152,000 on a $750,000 home, which is why price cuts alone rarely win this fight. At 7.11% with 10% down, a buyer's principal and interest only falls to the builder's $3,619 at a price of about $597,821. No Erie seller should plan on that.
Each $25,000 off the price lowers the payment by only about $151 at 7.11% with 10% down. A $15,812 buydown moves the year-one payment almost six times as much as a $25,000 cut, $872 versus $151. That is the core of the strategy: put your concession where the builder is putting theirs.
Should you offer a buydown credit or cut your price?
For most Erie resales near builder inventory, a buydown credit does more per dollar in the first two years, while a price cut lowers the payment for the life of the loan. The credit has limits you need to know before you write a number into a counteroffer.
Per the Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, for a principal residence or second home, the seller's financing concessions are capped at:
- 3% of the price or appraised value, whichever is lower, when the loan is over 90% of value.
- 6% when the loan is 75.01% to 90%. At 10% down on $750,000, that is up to $45,000.
- 9% when the loan is 75% or less.
The guide also says a seller-funded buydown counts toward that cap, and a concession can't be more than the buyer's closing costs. Anything above either limit is treated as a sales concession and comes off the price for the loan math.
The tradeoff is simple. A 2-1 buydown front-loads the savings into years one and two. A price cut is smaller each month but permanent, and it lowers the recorded sale price, which nearby sellers will see.
How much are Erie sellers giving up right now?
Erie homes sold at a $699,503 median over the three months ending October 2026, down 2.2% from a year earlier, per Redfin's Erie market page. The rest of Redfin's read:
- Median days on market: 55.
- Sale-to-list ratio: 98.4%.
- Homes with price drops: 48.0%.
For the Boulder County side of town, the Colorado Association of REALTORS October 2026 release says approximately 52% of Boulder and Broomfield county transactions include concessions averaging 5% of the price. On a $699,503 sale, 5% is about $34,975, more than double the $15,812 buydown above. Across the seven-county Denver metro, nearly 64% of October sales had concessions and 49% had price reductions. Homes that cut their asking price spent a median of 66 days on market, versus 9 days for homes that did not.
What can a resale offer that a builder can't?
A resale can beat a builder on four things a rate sheet does not show. Lead with them in your listing:
- A fixed rate for 30 years. Your buyer's loan does not reset after year seven.
- Finished extras already paid for: landscaping, fencing, window coverings and a finished basement where you have one.
- A known metro district or tax bill. Pull your tax statement and show the buyer your actual bill. If you are in the same district as the new builds, the levy is the same either way. See Erie property taxes in Weld vs. Boulder County.
- No build-out on your street. Your home is done, and your buyer can see what is next door.
Choose a buydown credit if:
- Builder listings with rate offers sit within a few blocks of your home.
- Your buyer pool needs a lower monthly payment to qualify comfortably.
- You can fund about 2% of the price without giving up more on price.
Choose a price cut if:
- Your home has passed Erie's 55-day median on market with few showings.
- Most of your buyers are paying cash or putting 25% or more down.
Choose to price at the market on day one if:
- Nearby resales, not builder listings, set your comps.
- You want to avoid the 66-day path that metro listings with a price cut followed.
"In Erie, a resale seller is not really fighting the builder's price. They are fighting the builder's payment. A $15,800 credit aimed at the rate does more in year one than a $25,000 cut, so I would rather put the money where the buyer feels it." Nick Ahrens, North Denver relocation specialist with eXp Realty.
Before you list, read how long it takes to sell a house in Erie, when and how much Lafayette sellers cut prices and the new construction vs. resale tradeoffs. Ready for numbers? Get a broker valuation on your home, search homes for sale for your next move, or call or text me at 949-230-3625.
Related reading for Erie sellers
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a resale seller in Erie pay for the buyer's rate buydown?
Yes. A seller can credit the buyer at closing to fund a temporary or permanent buydown. Under Fannie Mae's guide, that credit counts toward the seller concession cap, which is 6% of the price when the buyer puts 10% to just under 25% down.
What does a 2-1 buydown cost on a $750,000 Erie home?
About $15,812 with 10% down at a 7.11% note rate. Year one at 5.11% saves about $872 a month, and year two at 6.11% saves about $446. The buyer's lender sets the exact cost.
Is a 4.99% builder rate the same as a 4.99% 30-year fixed?
No. Westerly's advertised 4.99% is the initial rate on a 7/6 adjustable-rate mortgage. It is fixed for seven years and may adjust every six months after that, per the offer terms.
How long are Erie homes taking to sell?
A median of 55 days over the three months ending October 2026, per Redfin. About 48% of Erie listings had a price drop.
About Nick Ahrens
Nick Ahrens is a Colorado real estate broker with eXp Realty, specializing in Anthem, Baseline and the North Denver suburbs, including Erie. Call or text 949-230-3625, or visit youranthemhome.com.